Military History Monthly 2016 11.pdf

(28233 KB) Pobierz
November 2016 Issue 74 £4.50
www.military-history.org
THE WIPERS TIMES
Gallows humour at its best
TANKS
+
Over-hyped and overrated?
Jeremy Black analyses the
debut of the tank in WWI
Battle of the Alamo, 1836
IRON MAN OF
THE UNION
William T Sherman
ROOSEVELT VS
CHURCHILL
A tortured wartime relationship
MHM
MILITARY
November 2016 Issue 74 £4.50
www.military-history.org
THE WIPERS TIMES
Gallows humour at its best
TANKS
AN S
+
EDITORIAL ADVISORY BOARD:
Martin Brown
Archaeological Advisor, Defence
Estates, Ministry of Defence
Battle of the Alamo, 1836
attle f t e lamo, 83
Mark Corby
Military historian, lecturer, and
broadcaster
I
Paul Cornish
Curator, Imperial War Museum
Gary Gibbs
Assistant Curator, The Guards Museum
Angus Hay
Former Army Oicer, military
historian, and lecturer
Nick Hewitt
Historian, National Museum of the
Royal Navy, Portsmouth
Nigel Jones
Historian, biographer, and journalist
Alastair Massie
Head of Archives, Photos, Film, and
Sound, National Army Museum
Gabriel Moshenska
Research Fellow, Institute
of Archaeology, UCL
Colin Pomeroy
Squadron Leader, Royal Air Force
(Ret.), and historian
Michael Prestwich
Emeritus Professor of History,
University of Durham
Nick Saunders
Senior Lecturer, University of Bristol
s the tank now a military anachronism? Is it going
the way of the cavalry it replaced?
We pose the question and leave it hanging as
we mark the centenary of the debut of the tank in
September 1916. In our special this issue, Jeremy Black
assesses the military impact of the new weapon in the
second half of the First World War, while Arnold Harvey
selects some personal testimony from among the pioneers
of armoured warfare.
Then we have three very different American stories.
Fred Chiaventone recalls the epic last stand of a make-
shift Texas militia at the Alamo in 1836. Like many last
stands, it was the precursor to decisive victory – in this
case that of San Jacinto, which established the indepen-
dence of Texas.
Then Graham Goodlad continues our occasional
Great Commanders series with an assessment of
William Tecumseh Sherman, the iron man of the
Union in the American Civil War, while Nigel Hamilton
introduces his new study of the fraught wartime
relationship between President Roosevelt and
Prime Minister Churchill.
Finally, Patrick Mercer takes us into the hell of
Mametz Wood in July 1916, alongside that famous
(and very literary) British regiment, the Royal
Welch Fusiliers.
Over-hyped and overrated?
Jeremy Black analyses the
debut of the tank in WWI
IRON MAN OF
THE UNION
William T Sherman
Wi i m S r
ROOSEVELT VS
CHURCHILL
A tortured wartime relationship
tor
at e
on h p
ON THE COVER:
A Mark IV (Male) tank
ditched in a German trench near Ribecourt
during the Battle of Cambrai, 20 November
1917.
Credit:
Alamy
WHAT DO
YOU THINK?
Now you can have your opinions
on everything
MHM
heard online
as well as in print. Follow us on
Twitter @MilHistMonthly,
or
take a look at our Facebook page
for daily news, books, and article
updates at
www.facebook.com/
MilitaryHistoryMonthly.
Think you have spotted an error?
Disagree with a viewpoint? Enjoying
the mag? Visit
www.military-
history.org
to post your comments
on a wide range of diferent articles.
Alternatively, send an email to
feedback@military-history.org
Guy Taylor
Military archivist, and archaeologist
Julian Thompson
Major-General, Visiting Professor at
London University
Dominic Tweddle
Director-General, National Museum
of the Royal Navy
Greg Bayne
American Civil War Table of the UK
ADD US NOW
and have your say
CONTRIBUTORS
THIS MONTH’S EXPERTS
JEREMY BLACK
is Professor of
History at the
University of
Exeter. His many
books include
Naval Power, Air
Power, Rethinking Military History,
and
War and Technology.
FRED
CHIAVENTONE
is an historian,
retired cavalry
oicer, and Pro-
fessor Emeritus
for International
Security Afairs at the US Army’s
Command and General Staf College.
ARNOLD HARVEY
NIGEL HAMILTON
is a former univer-
is author of the
sity teacher and
award-winning
author of
Collision
Monty
trilogy, and,
of Empires: Britain
most recently,
in three world
Commander in
wars, 1793-1945,
Chief: FDR’s battle
with Churchill, 1943,
published by
Arnhem,
and
Body Politic: political
metaphor and political violence.
Biteback Publishing.
SUBSCRIBE NOW
Fill in the form on p.78 and
SAVE UP TO 20%
www.military-history.org
MILITARY
HISTORY
MONTHLY
3
November 2016 |
ISSUE 74
ON THE COVER
Tanks in the
First World War
Marking the centenary of the
birth of tank warfare, Jeremy
Black ofers an appraisal of the
successes and failures of the
irst tanks, and Arnold Harvey
explores the combat experience
of the irst tank crews.
INCLUDES:
Background
Technology
Combat experience
Exhibition
30
UPFRONT
Welcome
Letters
Notes from the Frontline
War Composers
Tim Rayborn on the wartime experiences
of Richard Strauss.
FEATURES
3
7
8
10
12
14
18
Roosevelt versus Churchill
A tortured wartime relationship
Nigel Hamilton investigates the relationship
between Winston Churchill and Franklin D
Roosevelt during the Second World War.
Behind the Image
Maria Earle looks at a photograph of
Cossack Bay, Balaklava, taken in 1855.
24
Iron Man of the Union
William T Sherman
Graham Goodlad reviews the
career of a controversial American
Civil War commander.
War Culture
George Clode marks the centenary of
the
irst edition of the trench newspaper
The Wipers Times.
44
‘A small afair’
The defence of the Alamo, 1836
Fred Chiaventone examines a critical
moment in the Texas Revolution.
54
REGIMENT
The Royal Welch Fusiliers
14
4
MILITARY
HISTORY
MONTHLY
Patrick Mercer explores the hell of
Mametz Wood in July 1916 from the
perspective of the Royal Welch Fusiliers.
November 2016
MHM
CONTENTS
www.military-history.org
Tel:
020 8819 5580
EDITORIAL
Editor:
Neil Faulkner
neil@military-history.org
Assistant Editor:
Hazel Blair
hazel.blair@currentpublishing.com
Books Editor:
Keith Robinson
books-editor@military-history.org
Editor-at-large:
Andrew Selkirk
andrew@military-history.org
Sub Editor:
Simon Coppock
Art Editor:
Mark Edwards
mark@currentpublishing.com
Designer:
Emma Simpson-Wells
Managing Editor:
Maria Earle
maria@currentpublishing.com
Managing Director:
Rob Selkirk
COMMERCIAL
Advertising Sales Manager:
Mike Traylen
T:
020 8819 5360
E:
mike@currentpublishing.com
Advertising Sales:
Nick Hayes
T:
020 8819 5361
E:
nick.hayes@currentpublishing.com
Marketing Manager:
Emma Watts-Plumpkin
T:
020 8819 5575
E:
emma@currentpublishing.com
Acting Business Manager:
Bree Forrer
T:
020 8819 5576
E:
bree.forrer@currentpublishing.com
Commercial Director:
Libby Selkirk
THE DEBRIEF
72
68
MHM
REVIEWS
Book of the Month
|
62
Robert Carver reviews
Hitler’s Soldiers
by Ben H Shepherd.
SUBSCRIPTIONS
UK:
£45.95 (12 issues)
RoW:
£55.95 (12 issues)
Back issues:
£5.50 each / £6.50 non-UK (inc p&p)
Binders:
(hold 12 copies) £15 / £20
Slip Cases:
(hold 12 copies) £15 / £20
MHM
VISITS
Museum
|
72
Fred Chiaventone reviews the US National
WWI Museum and Memorial.
Listings
|
74
The best military history events.
Military History Monthly
Subscriptions
Thames Works, Church Street, London, W4 2PD
Tel:
020 8819 5580
Fax:
020 8819 5589
subs@military-history.org
www.military-history.org/subscribe
B oks
|
64
ylor Downing reviews
August
14: France, the Great War, and
month that changed the world
rever;
Jules Stewart reviews
The Camisard Uprising;
and
ancesca Robinson reviews
ritish Concentration Camps.
NEWS DISTRIBUTION
MHM
OFF DUTY
Competition
|
80
Win one of three copies of
The Great War in the Middle
East
by Rob Johnson
.
UK & Rest of World:
COMAG, Tavistock Road,
West Drayton, UB7 7QE
Tel:
01895 444 055
Printed in England by William Gibbons
Military History Monthly
(ISSN 2048-4100) is
published monthly by Current Publishing Ltd,
Thames Works, Church Street, London, W4 2PD
© Current Publishing Ltd 2016
All rights reserved. Text and pictures are copyright restricted and must
not be reproduced without permission of the publishers. The publishers,
editors and authors accept no responsibility in respect of any goods,
promotions or services which may be advertised or referred to in this
magazine. Every efort has been made to secure permission for copyright
material. In the event of any material being used inadvertently or where
it has been impossible to contact the copyright owner, acknowledge-
ment will be made in a future issue. All liability for loss, disappointment,
negligence or damage caused by reliance on the information contained
within this publication is hereby excluded. The opinions expressed by
contributors are not necessarily those of the publisher.
n View
|
66
MHM’s
round-up of the best
ilitary history titles.
Brieing Room
|
82
All you need to know
about Tam Dalyell.
War on Film
|
68
aylor Downing reviews
Sink the Bismarck!
SUBSCRIBE |
MHM
OFFERS
Turn to
p.78
for subscriptions and special ofers.
www.military-history.org
Zgłoś jeśli naruszono regulamin